I play it once a year, and every time it's just as beautiful and refreshing as the last. You don't feel the twists the same way, but you'll still be amazed at the environments and details you missed.

I feel the same. I love Before the Storm so far, btw.
Hopefully I can come back to this game some time soon with a fresh look, even as I fondly remember it.
The only other place you can experience this kind of stuff is in nostalgic memories of real life experiences, which is why it's so immensely impactful.
I even remember some bad reviews or people that couldn't handle LiS and quit early, and that even they were deeply affected by this game. I'd like to hope it was a positive impact for them, paradoxically to what they'd tell you.

[The meaning of life is to give life meaning.
Three constants in life are Change, Paradox, and Humor ...
Blur your eyes and TRUST in your own profound experience.
Program your subconscious self-mastery...
All so that living in the present moment without time powers will be easier.]