Pros
Gameplay fluid and gunplay entertaining
Excellent enemy design
Great level design
Solid story with likeable characters (though there is not a whole lot of character development
Excellent Nazi killing simulator

Cons
Not nearly as many weapons as I was expecting
Limited replayability (play the campaign again in an alternative universe based on you choices or play with unlockable ingame cheats.

If you've beaten the game don't click new game unless you want to lose all your perks. I did this and lost all of them, but I enjoyed this game so much I went back and played the game again just to get them back.