Hogwarts Legacy invites you to step into the shoes of a wizard or witch in the late 19th century, delivering a visually stunning and magical experience that captures the atmosphere of the Harry Potter universe. From the moment you enter the Hogwarts grounds, it’s clear the developers poured immense effort into crafting an environment filled with charm, wonder, and nostalgia. While the game excels in creating a vivid magical atmosphere and engaging combat mechanics, it falls short in terms of narrative depth and quest design.


Pros

✪ Magical Atmosphere: The world is brimming with enchanting details, from secret passageways in Hogwarts to the lush landscapes of the Forbidden Forest and beyond.
✪ Combat Mechanics: The dueling system is surprisingly robust and engaging, offering plenty of spell combinations and strategies that make every encounter thrilling.
✪ Visuals and Audio: From the detailed interiors of Hogwarts to the ambient sounds of bustling Hogsmeade, the game’s aesthetics are phenomenal.

Cons

✪ Predictable Storyline: Despite its potential, the narrative lacks depth and often feels like a missed opportunity to explore more nuanced or surprising paths.
✪ Repetitive Quests: Side missions often boil down to fetch quests or simplistic tasks, failing to provide meaningful engagement or variety.


As someone who values immersive gameplay, I was delighted by the fluid and satisfying combat system. The ability to mix and match spells in dynamic ways added an extra layer of strategy to encounters, keeping me hooked for hours. Exploring the castle and its surrounding areas was equally enjoyable; every nook and cranny seemed to have a secret or collectible waiting to be discovered. The atmosphere and attention to detail were so strong that I found myself simply wandering around, soaking in the magic.

However, the quests and storyline left much to be desired. While I expected the narrative to weave a complex web of intrigue, it instead delivered predictable and shallow outcomes. The main questline lacked memorable twists, and side missions often felt like filler. I kept hoping for more significant consequences to my actions or surprises along the way, but they never materialized.


Hogwarts Legacy is a visual and gameplay marvel that captures the essence of the Wizarding World but misses its mark on storytelling. If you’re looking for an immersive and visually captivating adventure with solid combat mechanics, this game will surely enchant you. However, if you prioritize deep narratives and meaningful quests, you might find the experience a bit underwhelming.

Rating:

8.5 /10

A must-play for fans of the franchise, but with room for improvement in its storytelling.

I paused my playthrough to finish Metaphor ReFantazio (this ended up being one of my personal GOTY, showcasing how engaging storytelling and amazing mechanics can keep players invested) and Dragon Age: The Veilguard (even with its very horrible writing felt more engaging at times). Every time I returned to Hogwarts Legacy with an attempt to reignite my excitement, I always find myself putting it down again shortly after.

Growing up with the Harry Potter series, I was really excited when the game was announced, knowing I can finally explore Hogwarts, and exploring the magical world I’d dreamed about for so long felt like fulfilling a childhood fantasy. And in many ways, the game delivered on that promise: the world-building was beautiful, rich, and very detailed. Flying over the castle grounds, weaving between towers, and exploring hidden corridors was really satisfying.

However the longer I played, the magic started to fade. The main story was freaking flat. It’s missing the depth and intrigue that made the Harry Potter series interesting. The writing imo, is uninspired and not strong enough to keep me engaged.

The NPCs were another major letdown. While the environment around them felt alive, they felt dull and robotic without any real personality. They’re missing the quirks and charm that would make them memorable or make me care about their stories.

The fun of exploring couldn't make up for the terrible writing. It’s not a bad game by any means, it just didn’t capture the magic I hoped for. I knowI'm in the minority here. Here's to hoping for some improvement in the sequel!

It's the perfect Harry Potter game !!

Wow, I didn't think it would be this good.
A must, not just for Harry Potter fans


Just walking through Hogwarts is so nostalgic and perfectly executed

I can't understand why it wasn't listed at the Game Awards (Goty) 2023


I would really give the game a 10/10